About Us
Established February 25, 1882
All-Star Mutual and Newark Mutual merged companies in July 2015. Our writing territory includes the counties of Dane, Iowa, Columbia, Richland, Vernon, Crawford, Grant, Sauk, Adams, Green, Juneau, Lafayette, Rock, Jefferson, Walworth and Dodge. With our friendly staff and helpful agents, we are a wonderful mutual company to work with.
The products and services we offer
Recommendations Received (5)
"Kristi brings knowledge, enthusiasm, and professionalism to handle all your insurance needs from..."
Read more
"Kristi brings knowledge, enthusiasm, and professionalism to handle all your insurance needs from finding the right coverage to supporting you when life happens. I’ve had the opportunity to know Kristi for 5 years and she has always gone above and beyond to help her colleagues. "
"All-Star/Newark Mutual Insurance is a wonderful local company that works hard for it's customers!"
Products & Services
Recommendations Given (5)
"Tom is very professional and knowledgeable in his field, "
"Julie has worked at Pierce for many years and is great at finding the right piece of furniture..."
Read more
"Julie has worked at Pierce for many years and is great at finding the right piece of furniture you're looking for! Her customer service is phenomenal. "
