How Do You Hire a Good Instuctor?
Being an instructor myself, this question has gone through my mine several times. Thoughts??
16 Comments
840 Views
Being an instructor myself, this question has gone through my mine several times. Thoughts??
Answers (1-10)
Teaching is definitely its own skill. For our process, we are looking for three essential skills: the first is their ability to present a subject in a logical and clear fashion that builds the student's knowledge.
Next is how well they can handle questions - Are they respectful of the student in their answers. Do they take the time to understand the question if it is not entirely clear. Can they utilize more than one option to explain their answer (including audio, visual and the use of metaphors and analogies). If the question is not part of the topic at hand, how skillful are they at giving just enough information to let the person know they have heard their question but that they are not going to give a full answer because it is not an the appropriate venue or sufficient time right then.
Third is their ability to accept and incorporate feedback from students on how successfully they were able to teach.
First, you have to find a good possible source. Try online discussion groups focused on the area you need a good instructor in. If you are involved in some, ask. Otherwise, just watch for a while, then ask.
When you find some likely candidates, check out their credentials - experience, schooling, past and current responsibilities. Does anything in their cv indicate teaching or mentoring? If so, you may have someone worth talking to.
Once past the phone and ftf interview, if you have others who can join you, do as James Bologa advised. Have them present a short class in an area they would be responsible for if hired. Then evaluate their performance (1) against your standards & (2) against others you may have taken thus far in you hiring process.
Then decide.
Instructor in what subject? Look at character (reliability; patience; calmness; reputation with others; integrity); and also subject matter skill. In interview, most important to guage level of interest and motivation to take job. If the applicant asks too much about "money", this is NOT the type of interest that will be useful in an employment situation; because he/she will leave as soon as more money becomes available elsewhere; or the job encounters problems that look like "it's not worth the money".
Knowing something and being able to teach it to others are 2 different things. I’ve had teachers who were brilliant in their field but could not communicate that skill to save their lives. A good instructor has either been instructed In Pedagogy or are gifted at being able to look at the topic and be able to take it apart and put it together in front of students in a way that both motivates the student to learn it and clearly communicates the topic/skill. Have them do a demo of a short lesson for you. Or share how they would cover it. What ways do they present the information? Visual aides? Verbal communication? How do the students get to interact in the learning process? All are so important.
In our unique situation, I know our training can handle the "instructing" side...I look for a certain emotional IQ in candidates (read: birds land on their shoulder) that tells me I can put them in front of any of our students and they will have the patience and work ethic to meet the needs of the individual at their level and grow them from there.
That's a great question because some people interview very well, but sometimes prove to be different once they're hired. I would definitely have them present in front of you because that will help determine whether or not they're the right fit for the job. Good luck.
I can suggest letting the prospective hire teach the class and you observe. Open communication and feedback afterwards. Look for the qualities in anyone like their passion, commitment, experience and level of ability. Then mentor.
Look at past experience in teaching. Have them do a mock presentation for you. Ask them what was the most difficult situation they encountered in instructing (situation, what they did, outcome) as that can be a predictor of future behavior. Develop questions around the key qualities you are looking for (energy, dedication to instructing, SME etc.) whatever fits for you. How do they keep on top of changes in this field of knowledge? Check references.
Hiring good people really comes down to spending the time up front defining the position. Focus on outcomes, not duties and responsibilities. What is it you want this person to accomplish? How will your company/organization be different because this person in on board and performing well? How will you know if this person has been successful after 3 month? 9 months? 1 year? These should be measurable (SMART) goals. Once you have defined the position well, then you can advertise those things.....not duties and responsibilities. This will attract better people. Advertise your organizational purpose and how this person will impact that purpose.
Also, if you think about why people leave organizations, it's not because of something that can be found on a resume or application, or even in an interview (unless you know exactly what the risk is with each candidate). People leave organizations because they don't fit the job, the manager or the team. Period. Use a good employment assessment (not personality assessment) that measures "core trait" or "true trait" not personality. We recommend the ProfileXT. This tool will help you define the behavioral aspects of the position, find the risks with each candidate and help you interview more effectively around those areas of risk so you can make a more informed hiring decision.
Best of luck to you!
Kim Leifsen
Joseph, that's a pretty broad question. I don't make a habit of answering a questionwith a question but, the first thing that comes to mind is "for what subject?". If it's for a trade or arts area (i.e. carpentry or music) experience is important. Not so much in the strictly intellectual areas. However temprement is always a consideration. A resume usually answers the first issue. You need to explore their temprement during an interview or asking current students.